View Past Issues
SMART IDEA #147: Making your service “unreasonable” Great service isn't a differentiator if every competitor claims it too. A simple exercise for mapping - and fixing - your client experience, moment by moment.
SMART IDEAS Weekly

Weekly inspiration for the staffing industry

ISSUE #147  |  August 15, 2026

New this Week:

• Making your service “unreasonable”

• Meet RogIQ: your marketing superpower

• Free SEO/AIO Site Review

SMART IDEA #147:

Making your service “unreasonable”

David Searns | Co-CEO

If service is your differentiator, prove it

 

A few months ago, Vicki and I attended the Unreasonable Hospitality conference. We came home inspired—and with pages of ideas.

 

That experience led to two SMART IDEAS articles. In the first, I shared five lessons from the conference, including the critical distinction between service and hospitality: service is what you deliver; hospitality is how you make people feel.

 

In the second, Vicki explained that hospitality does not mean over-servicing, giving away free work, or relying on heroic individual efforts. It means consistently delivering what you promised while intentionally improving the human experience.

 

Read the first: Smart Idea 130

Read the second: Smart Idea 131

 

But inspiration is the easy part.

 

This past week, we brought the Haley Marketing team together for our annual Summer Summit—this year, we are celebrating our company’s 30th birthday with a theme of “Making Magic Happen.”

 

Our focus for the past three days has been to put Unreasonable Hospitality into action. We mapped our service processes, examined hundreds of client touchpoints, identified friction, brainstormed improvements, and committed to specific changes.

 

We learned that creating unreasonable hospitality is not one grand gesture. It is hundreds of small decisions, deliberately designed and consistently delivered.

 

Why “great service” is a weak differentiator

 

Ask 10 staffing company owners what makes their firm different, and most will say some version of:

 

We provide better service.

We care more.

We are more responsive.

We build relationships.

We go the extra mile.

 

The problem is that their competitors are saying exactly the same things.

 

Service is also difficult to differentiate because it is abstract. “Great service” means something different to every job seeker—and every employer.

 

Unless you define the experience precisely, your service quality depends on who answers the phone, which recruiter handles the order, how busy the team is, and whether someone remembers to go the extra mile.

 

Most companies also evaluate service from the inside out. They document what employees are supposed to do, but they do not fully examine what clients and candidates see, hear, do, wait for, worry about, or feel.

 

You cannot differentiate with an intention. You need to design an experience.

 

SMART IDEAS Summit 6 Logo

Building Your Growth Engine

14 sessions of real growth strategies.

Tuesday, September 29, 2026

Reserve Your Seat

*Free to attend, but seats are limited

 

Step one: Map the entire journey

 

Start by selecting one journey, such as:

 

A prospect becoming a client.

A new client being onboarded.

A candidate applying and interviewing.

A temporary employee beginning an assignment.

A client reporting a service problem.

A customer receiving an invoice or renewing an agreement.

 

Map the journey chronologically, from the very first interaction through the final follow-up.

 

The key is granularity. “Onboarding” is not one touchpoint. It might include the welcome email, kickoff scheduling, introductions, information gathering, expectation-setting, training, status updates, and the first results review.

 

Capture everything—even moments that seem insignificant. The hold music matters. The automated email matters. The sales-to-recruiting handoff matters. Silence while someone waits for an answer matters.

 

If you get stuck, ask:

 

What happens immediately before this?

What happens immediately after?

Who owns this moment?

What does the client have to do?

What might the client be thinking or feeling?

 

Step two: Color-code every touchpoint

 

Once the journey is visible, evaluate each touchpoint honestly:

 

Green: Consistently great. The experience works well and meets or exceeds expectations.

 

Red: A recurring source of friction, confusion, anxiety, delay, or disappointment.

 

Blue: Neutral or overlooked. Nothing is necessarily wrong, but nothing memorable is happening either.

 

Red moments demand attention because they leak trust and goodwill. Before adding delight, fix the basic service failures.

 

But your Blue moments may represent the greatest opportunity. These are the “hidden cards”—the ordinary interactions competitors overlook because no one thinks of them as important.

 

A confirmation email, handoff, status update, first-day check-in, invoice, or assignment-ending conversation can become surprisingly memorable when someone finally designs it with care.

 

Step three: Elevate the experience

 

Evaluate each touchpoint through two lenses:

 

Convenience: How can we make this easier, faster, clearer, or less stressful?

 

Hospitality: How can we make this more personal, thoughtful, memorable, or delightful?

 

Then ask four questions:

 

1. What friction are we creating?

2. What magic could we create?

3. What is one simple improvement we could make immediately?

4. What would the audacious version look like if we redesigned this from scratch?

 

When deciding how to elevate your experience, consider three levels of improvement:

 

First, make it easier.

Then make it memorable.

Finally, imagine how to make it magical.

 

Focus your service improvement efforts on four parts of the journey:

 

  1. The start – creating a great first impression.
  2. Elevating the overlooked (those blue steps).
  3. Transforming the biggest pain points.
  4. The end – ensuring a great ending.

 

Step four: Turn the best ideas into systems

 

A great idea is not a service strategy.

 

Prioritize ideas based on impact and effort. Select at least one low-cost improvement that can be implemented quickly and one more ambitious idea worth developing.

 

Then define:

 

Who owns the touchpoint?

What triggers the action?

Where does the necessary information live?

What does “done right” look like?

How will you know whether clients value it?

How will you ensure it happens consistently?

 

If the experience depends on one exceptional employee remembering to do something, you do not have a system. You have a hero.

 

The ultimate goal is to create systems that deliver hospitality consistently—while still giving people enough freedom to listen, care, personalize, and respond like human beings.

 

Stop saying it. Start designing it.

 

Nearly every staffing firm claims to deliver superior service.

 

Far fewer can show exactly where and how their experience is different.

 

Map one journey. Color-code it honestly. Fix the Red. Elevate the Blue. Protect the Green. Then build systems that allow your team to deliver those moments again and again.

 

That is how service stops being a claim and becomes a competitive advantage.

 

RogIQ – make marketing your superpower.

There’s finally a marketing OS that fits the way staffing actually works.

▼

▸ SIGNAL INTERCEPTED

RogIQ

Have you seen RogIQ (Rogue IQ) - the AI marketing assistant built for small teams who refuse to think small?

+ Analyze your business and brand
+ Build your strategy
+ Create your campaigns based on deep persona-driven content
+ Track your performance (blogs, SEO, social, and more)
+ Optimize your marketing… all in ONE platform!

RogIQ engines

Five AI-powered engines. One rebellious platform. Zero excuses.

Learn More

haleymarketing.com

SMART IDEAS

1.888.696.2900

facebook-noshare twitter-noshare instagram-noshare youtube-noshare pinterest-noshare linkedin-noshare
Haley Marketing | PO Box 410 | Williamsville, NY 14231-0410 | 716-631-8981
This email was sent to:
Update my info   Unsubscribe